Post Karma vs Comment Karma: What’s the Difference?

The short answer

Here is the simplest possible comparison:

Type	Comes from	Best for	Usually easier for new users?
Post karma	Upvotes on posts	Building visibility through original posts	No
Comment karma	Upvotes on comments	Building trust through conversations	Yes

That is the core difference.

But in practice, there is more to it than that.

What is post karma?

Post karma is the karma you earn when other Reddit users upvote a post you created.

That includes things like:

a question you posted in a subreddit

a discussion thread you started

a story, meme, image, or link post

an original post sharing an opinion, experience, or resource

If people respond positively and upvote your post, your post karma can increase.

Post karma is useful because it shows that you can create content people want to engage with.

For some subreddits, that matters a lot.

What is comment karma?

Comment karma is the karma you earn when other Reddit users upvote your comments.

That includes things like:

replying to someone’s question

adding your opinion to a discussion

sharing advice under another user’s post

making a helpful, funny, or interesting observation in the comments

If your comments get upvoted, your comment karma can increase.

Comment karma often matters more for beginners because it is usually the fastest way to build a normal-looking participation history.

The biggest difference in real life

The formal definition is simple.

But the real difference is strategic.

Post karma is about creating threads.

Comment karma is about joining threads.

That difference matters because joining existing conversations is usually easier than starting strong new ones.

Here is a more practical comparison:

Factor	Post karma	Comment karma
How you earn it	Create posts that get upvoted	Leave comments that get upvoted
What it signals	You can create content others engage with	You can participate well in conversations
Difficulty level	Higher	Lower
Typical starting point for new users	Harder	Better
Risk of removal for new accounts	Often higher	Often lower
Best early use case	Testing a few beginner-friendly posts	Building trust steadily

For most new Reddit users, comment karma is the better first move.

Why comment karma is usually easier to build

There are a few reasons.

1. Comments require less commitment from readers

A user may not want to upvote a whole new post from an unknown account, but they may upvote a useful comment if it adds value.

2. Comments fit naturally into existing discussions

You do not need to invent a whole thread idea. You just need to respond well.

3. Comments often face fewer barriers

Some subreddits are stricter with posts than with comments, especially for newer accounts.

4. You can spread your effort across multiple conversations

Instead of betting everything on one post, you can leave several strong comments in relevant communities.

That is why many users trying to grow a new Reddit account start with comment karma first.

It is also why RedditMaster can be especially useful early on. Better reply suggestions can help users participate more naturally and build momentum faster.

Why post karma still matters

Even though comment karma is often easier, post karma still has real value.

Post karma shows that you can create content that stands on its own.

That matters because:

some subreddits may care more about posting credibility

strong posts can earn more visibility than comments

posting well can help build authority in a niche

if you want to use Reddit strategically, eventually you will want both

Think of it this way:

Comment karma helps prove you can join the room.

Post karma helps prove you can lead a conversation in the room.

Which one matters more for subreddit restrictions?

There is no universal rule.

Different subreddits may care about different things.

Some only care that your account has enough general trust.

Some seem to care more about comment history.

Some may silently filter low-karma posters regardless of the exact mix.

A practical way to think about it is this:

Situation	Which type often matters more?	Why
Brand-new user trying to look legitimate	Comment karma	Easier way to build trust history
User trying to submit original posts in stricter communities	Post karma or combined karma	Posting restrictions may be tighter
User trying to look broadly established	Both	A balanced profile looks more natural
User trying to participate safely at the beginning	Comment karma	Lower-friction starting point

If you do not know what a subreddit prefers, building comment karma first is usually the safer move.

Post karma vs comment karma for beginners

If your account is new and your goal is to stop getting blocked, here is the best way to think about it.

Do not ask:

“Which one is theoretically better?”

Ask:

“Which one helps me become a normal-looking Reddit account faster?”

For most people, the answer is comment karma.

That is because beginners usually struggle with these problems:

their posts get filtered

their account looks too new

their content may accidentally sound promotional

they do not yet understand subreddit culture

Comments solve a lot of that.

They let you build trust without forcing you to start every conversation yourself.

Post karma vs comment karma for founders and marketers

If you are using Reddit for business purposes, the distinction matters even more.

A lot of founders make the mistake of focusing too early on posts because they think posting is the fastest way to get attention.

Usually, it is not.

For business users, comment karma is often the better first step because it helps you build credibility before you try to post anything with business intent.

Here is a practical comparison:

Goal	Better first focus	Why
Unblock a new Reddit account	Comment karma	Faster trust-building
Start participating in niche communities	Comment karma	Lower risk and more natural
Build long-term authority	Both	You need balance over time
Promote something later without looking spammy	Comment karma first, then post karma	Trust before visibility

This is one reason RedditMaster is useful for business users. Instead of pushing aggressive automation, it helps users prepare better replies and posts with a manual-review workflow that fits Reddit better.

Which type grows faster?

Usually, comment karma grows faster for new users.

That does not mean every comment will perform well. It just means the path is more forgiving.

One post can fail completely.

Several useful comments can still build momentum.

Here is a simple growth comparison:

Approach	Speed potential	Risk	Best for
Trying to earn mostly post karma from day one	Sometimes high, often inconsistent	Higher	Users who already understand Reddit culture
Building mostly comment karma first	More steady	Lower	Most beginners
Building both at the same time	Balanced	Medium	Users with some Reddit experience

For most users, steady is better than flashy.

Common mistakes people make

A lot of Reddit users misunderstand how these two karma types should be used.

Here are some of the most common mistakes:

Mistake	Why it hurts	Better move
Focusing only on post karma too early	Posts are harder to land with a new account	Build comment karma first
Leaving generic comments just to farm karma	Low-quality comments get ignored or downvoted	Make comments specific and useful
Assuming all karma is treated the same everywhere	Different subreddits filter differently	Build a healthy mix over time
Posting promotional content before building trust	Makes the account look suspicious	Participate normally first
Ignoring subreddit culture	Good content in one subreddit may flop in another	Adapt tone and style to each community

If you avoid these mistakes, both post karma and comment karma become much easier to build.

What should new users focus on first?

For most new users, the best order is:

Step 1: Build comment karma

Leave useful replies in relevant subreddits.

Step 2: Learn subreddit culture

Watch what gets upvoted and what gets ignored.

Step 3: Test a few low-risk posts

Once your account looks more natural, start trying posts.

Step 4: Build both over time

The strongest Reddit accounts usually have a healthy balance.

This is also where RedditMaster fits well. It can help new users come up with better reply ideas first, then gradually move into stronger post ideas once the account has more credibility.

A practical example

Let’s say two new users both start at zero.

User A tries to earn karma mostly by making posts.

User B focuses first on useful comments.

Here is what usually happens:

User	Strategy	Typical result
User A	Posts immediately in multiple subreddits	More removals, slower trust-building
User B	Comments consistently in relevant discussions	More natural growth, better early account history

This is not always true in every case, but it is the more common pattern.

That is why comment karma is usually the better starting point.

Does Reddit show them separately?

Yes, Reddit generally distinguishes between post karma and comment karma on your profile.

That separation is useful because it tells both users and moderators something about how your account has built its reputation.

For example:

high comment karma may suggest strong community participation

high post karma may suggest strong content creation ability

a balance of both usually looks healthier than relying on only one

Do you eventually need both?

Yes, in most cases.

If your goal is simply to get unblocked, comment karma may be enough to get started.

But if your goal is to become a stronger Reddit user over time, you will usually want both:

comment karma for trust and interaction

post karma for visibility and authority

That is the long-term play.

Watch the RedditMaster video

If you want a more practical workflow for building Reddit traction, improving your replies, and creating stronger posts with a safer manual-review process, watch the RedditMaster video here:

RedditMaster video:

Suggested callout copy for this section:

Want a faster way to build Reddit credibility with better comment and post suggestions? Watch the RedditMaster walkthrough.

Final answer

So, what is the difference between post karma and comment karma?

Post karma comes from upvotes on your posts.

Comment karma comes from upvotes on your comments.

Post karma shows that you can create content people want to engage with.

Comment karma shows that you can participate well in ongoing discussions.

Both matter, but for most beginners, comment karma is the easier and smarter place to start.

If your account is new, building comment karma first usually gives you the best chance to look more credible, avoid friction, and eventually earn post karma more easily too.

And if you want help with that process, RedditMaster can support it by helping you generate better reply ideas and stronger post suggestions that you can review and manually copy into Reddit.

FAQ

Is comment karma better than post karma?

Not always, but for most new users it is the easier and more practical starting point.

Can I build a good Reddit account with only comment karma?

You can build early trust that way, but over time a healthy mix of both is better.

Why do my posts get removed even if I have some comment karma?

Because subreddits may also care about post karma, account age, rules, and overall account behavior.

Which should founders focus on first?

Usually comment karma first, because it helps build credibility before posting anything that could look promotional.

Can RedditMaster help with both?

Yes. RedditMaster can help users prepare stronger replies and post ideas so they can participate more effectively with a manual-review workflow.